I've read lots of first time stories. I certainly do remember mine.
I was 17 at the time and had just started dating. On this evening, I had a date with this girl named Cindy. She was 16 at the time and I knew her dad personally from where I worked part time. So, I was going to be a perfect gentleman with Cindy.
I picked her up at seven. We ate out together and then went to a movie. We sat toward the back of the theater and the movie wasn't all that great. Next thing I knew, Cindy and I were kissing. We really got into it and decided to leave. We got in my car (which was my dad's Buick) and continued to kiss and make out with each other. I sure wasn't expecting anything like this. Out of nowhere, Cindy's hand went down between my legs. I was all aroused and had a big hardon going and Cindy put her hand around it thru my pants. I had never had a girl touch me there before and I was very excited. She then went for my zipper pulling it down and she reached in grabbing my cock and pulling it out. This was another first. First time a girl had ever seen my cock. She then went to stroking it. I could tell that this wasn't Cindy's first time. She then reached in her purse and pulled out a hand full of tissue paper. She knew exactly what she was doing and knew exactly what was going to happen after a few minutes. When I went to breathing fast and moving my hips, she laid my cock forward with the tissue paper at the head and she said 'Cum for me baby' just as it hit and I started shooting. She caught all the cum and put the tissue in the trash bag in the car.
I then took Cindy home and when I dropped her off I made another date with her for the next weekend. I wanted more of this. At work the next time I went, I was with her dad and he immediately asked me if it was good! It was like he knew. I couldn't believe it. On our next date I also got to touch Cindy between her legs, fingering her. We ended up just having 'sex dates' as it turned out. Wonder what ever happened to that girl. I'd sure like to see her once again just for old time sake (and one of her great hand jobs!)