Gooey give it a go
It was a hot summer's night, and with nothing to do I decided to stay over at my friend Jims house and brought along 'American pie' as I had recommended to Jim.
After the hilarity had ended me and Jim began discussing the pie based antics featured in the film. Jim persisted in assuring me that it would be fun if we re-enacted it the pie scene...together.
This startled me as it was out Jim's character to make such a comment, but I couldn't help but be slightly curious... We have engaged in mutual masturbation before with our good lady friend Christine and it was a lot of fun, but we had never done it without her and the mere suggestion of pie seemed slightly odd...but in the end I said 'what the hey.'
Obviously we didn't have any pie in the house, but Jim was so up for the idea he quickly ran to the store to buy one. While he was gone I sat tense, wondering what the experience would be like...and if it would go ahead. As he said he would, he rushed back with a freshly baked apple pie, I was so excited at this point I just had to have a quickie before he returned and I had prepared the porn.
We nervously undressed but Jim gave me a reassuring stroke and everything seemed ok.
This was one of the most exciting experiences in my life, and Jim had already started playing the pie, he said he it was great but sadly his huge manhood had already pierced the soft warm pie and it was in pieces.
I was extremely disappointed but suddenly I felt the warm moist texture of the pie rubbing my tingling body, at this point I was about to explode, and felt my hard veiny shaft being rubbed by the baked goods, it felt good. I rubbed Jim's balls with the warm apple goo, I think he really enjoyed this because shortly after he came all over my hand, this was too much for me and I exploded all over Jims face. After a mad cum fest, we licked the left over pie off each other's body.
This was my first gay experience, but it certainly wasn't my last. Although we have not done it again, it is a memory that will stay close to me in my mind and in my pants.